How Much Does Gutter Replacement Cost?

Gutters may not be the most glamorous part of your home, but they play a critical role in preventing water damage, basement flooding, soil erosion, and even siding deterioration. When they’re damaged or outdated, replacing them becomes essential — but how much will that cost?

In Wisconsin, the average cost of gutter replacement ranges from $900 to $2,500, depending on several variables. Let’s break down the six key factors that affect your total cost so you know what to expect before hiring a professional.

1. Type of Gutter Material

The material of your new gutters is the biggest cost factor — and it also affects durability and appearance.

Vinyl Gutters are the most budget-friendly option, costing $3–$5 per linear foot. They’re lightweight and easy to install, but not as durable in cold or extreme climates.
Aluminum Gutters ($6–$12 per linear foot) strike a good balance between affordability, longevity, and weather resistance — making them one of the most popular choices.
Steel Gutters ($9–$20 per linear foot) are strong and durable but prone to rust over time unless properly treated.
Copper Gutters ($25–$45 per linear foot) are premium and stunning but are more of a long-term investment due to their high upfront cost.
Zinc Gutters ($20–$40 per linear foot) offer a sleek look and excellent longevity with minimal maintenance.

👉 Pro Tip: If you want durability without breaking the bank, aluminum is often the sweet spot.

2. Total Length of Gutters Needed

The size of your home dictates how much guttering you’ll need. Most homes require between 100 and 300 linear feet of gutter. Multiply this by the price per foot (material + labor), and you get your base cost.

For example:

If you need 200 feet of aluminum gutters at $8 per foot = $1,600

Larger homes or multi-story buildings will naturally cost more due to the additional materials and labor.

3. Labor and Installation Costs

Installation isn’t just about hanging gutters — it requires expertise, especially if your roofline is complex or your home is tall. Labor typically adds $2 to $7 per linear foot.

Labor costs increase based on:

Number of stories: Second-story or roofline work may require scaffolding or special equipment.
Roof complexity: More angles and corners = more custom cuts and fittings.
Seamless gutters: These are made on-site and require skilled labor, but they reduce leak risks.

Labor usually makes up 30% to 50% of your total cost, so it’s worth hiring experienced contractors.

4. Gutter Style and Design

Gutter style impacts not only aesthetics but also functionality and cost:

K-Style Gutters (most common) resemble crown molding and can handle more water flow.
Half-Round Gutters are typically found on older or historic homes. They’re more decorative but less efficient in heavy rainfall.
Box Gutters are built into the roof or fascia and are often custom-made, making them one of the most expensive options.

Also, some homeowners may require oversized gutters to handle heavy downpours — this adds to both material and labor costs.

5. Downspouts and Add-ons

Your gutter system isn’t complete without downspouts and optional upgrades like:

Downspouts: Direct water away from your foundation. They cost around $5–$15 per foot.
Splash Blocks: These prevent soil erosion by spreading out the flow of water from the downspouts.
Gutter Guards: Optional but helpful, especially if you have trees nearby. They block leaves and debris, reducing the need for frequent cleaning. Prices vary from $1.50 to $10 per foot depending on the type.

👉 Pro Tip: Installing gutter guards during replacement saves on future cleaning and repair costs.

6. Removal of Old Gutters

If you’re replacing existing gutters, you’ll also need to remove and dispose of the old ones. This can cost an additional $100 to $300, depending on the contractor and the condition of the existing system.

Some companies include removal in their installation quote, while others list it separately — always confirm before signing a contract.

Gutter Replacement Cost by Material (Installed)

Material	Price Per Linear Foot	200 ft Total (Avg.)
Vinyl	$5 – $8	$1,000 – $1,600
Aluminum	$8 – $14	$1,600 – $2,800
Steel	$10 – $20	$2,000 – $4,000
Copper	$30 – $50	$6,000 – $10,000
Zinc	$20 – $40	$4,000 – $8,000

Final Thoughts

Replacing your gutters is an investment that protects your roof, foundation, and landscaping. By understanding these six cost factors, you’ll be able to make smarter decisions, budget more accurately, and avoid surprise expenses.

Whether you’re going for a basic replacement or upgrading to a premium material, it’s essential to work with experienced professionals who stand behind their work.

Need Reliable Gutter Services in Wisconsin? Trust Solid Exteriors

If you’re located in Wisconsin, we highly recommend Solid Exteriors — a trusted, family-owned business serving Arcadia and the surrounding counties. Their team specializes in roofing, concrete, siding, and gutter services, with a reputation built on quality craftsmanship and honest pricing.

Why choose Solid Exteriors?

Licensed and insured professionals
Tailored recommendations and transparent quotes
Serving Trempealeau, Eau Claire, La Crosse, Buffalo, and beyond
Over a decade of experience in exterior home improvements

👉 Visit solidexteriorswi.com to schedule your free consultation and see how they can help you protect your home with high-quality gutter replacement.